Bobcat S630 vs CAT 246D: A Comprehensive Comparison
When it comes to compact skid steer loaders, two of the most recognized brands in the industry are Bobcat and Caterpillar (CAT). The Bobcat S630 and CAT 246D are both excellent choices for various tasks such as landscaping, construction, and material handling. However, choosing between the two models can be difficult, especially since both machines offer distinct features and capabilities. In this article, we will explore the key differences and similarities between the Bobcat S630 and CAT 246D to help you make an informed decision.
Bobcat S630: Key Features and Performance
The Bobcat S630 is part of Bobcat’s M-Series, a range of skid steer loaders known for their power, versatility, and ease of operation. The S630 model, specifically, is a mid-size skid steer that offers excellent lift capacity and superior hydraulic performance.
Engine and Power
The Bobcat S630 is powered by a 2.4L turbocharged diesel engine, delivering robust performance in a compact form. The engine offers both power and efficiency, allowing the S630 to handle demanding tasks while remaining fuel-efficient.- Engine: 2.4L turbocharged diesel engine
- Horsepower: 74.3 hp
- Rated operating capacity: 2,300 lbs
- Operating weight: 7,763 lbs
- Maximum lift height: 122 inches
Hydraulic System
The S630’s hydraulic system provides exceptional lift and breakout force. With its high-flow hydraulics, it can operate a wide variety of attachments, making it a versatile tool on the job site. The machine’s auxiliary hydraulics offer up to 24.5 gallons per minute (GPM), which is ideal for running high-demand attachments such as hydraulic breakers, augers, and trenchers.- Auxiliary hydraulic flow: 24.5 GPM
- Hydraulic pressure: 3,500 psi
Operator Comfort and Control
Bobcat has put considerable effort into enhancing operator comfort and usability with the S630. The loader features a spacious cab with improved visibility, air conditioning, and a fully adjustable seat. The S630 also includes Bobcat’s advanced joystick controls, which allow the operator to control the loader and its attachments with ease.- Cab: Spacious with excellent visibility
- Controls: Advanced joystick control with options for proportional control on hydraulics
- Suspension: Standard suspension undercarriage for smoother operation
Performance and Maneuverability
The S630 offers strong maneuverability with its powerful drivetrain and high ground clearance, making it ideal for working in rough or uneven terrain. Its ability to operate in tight spaces, combined with its excellent breakout force and lifting capabilities, gives it an edge for various construction applications.- Max travel speed: 7.5 mph
- Turning radius: 74 inches (tight)
CAT 246D: Key Features and Performance
The CAT 246D is a part of the Caterpillar line of skid steer loaders. Known for its durability and heavy-duty performance, the 246D offers a high level of comfort, control, and lifting capacity. This model is designed to provide superior stability and power on the job site, especially when working with tough materials or attachments.
Engine and Power
The CAT 246D is powered by a 2.2L turbocharged diesel engine that offers a balance of fuel efficiency and power. With slightly lower horsepower than the S630, the 246D compensates with higher operating weight and a reputation for longer operational lifespan.- Engine: 2.2L turbocharged diesel engine
- Horsepower: 74.3 hp
- Rated operating capacity: 2,400 lbs
- Operating weight: 7,775 lbs
- Maximum lift height: 121 inches
Hydraulic System
The hydraulic system on the CAT 246D is designed to provide excellent power for handling demanding attachments. The high-flow option for this model is perfect for tasks requiring significant hydraulic force, such as powering planers, brooms, and other large attachments.- Auxiliary hydraulic flow: 23.8 GPM
- Hydraulic pressure: 3,200 psi (standard)
- High-flow option: 33.2 GPM
Operator Comfort and Control
CAT has designed the 246D with operator comfort and ease of use in mind. The cab is spacious and offers great visibility, and the controls are intuitive, with the option for joystick or foot controls. The ride control system also reduces machine bounce, providing a smoother ride for the operator.- Cab: Roomy with excellent all-around visibility
- Controls: Ergonomic joystick control with options for foot control
- Suspension: Optional ride control system for improved ride comfort
Performance and Maneuverability
The CAT 246D is built for handling heavy-duty tasks with ease. Its heavy-duty construction, higher-rated capacity, and strong lift capabilities make it suitable for handling tough materials and working in rugged environments. The 246D also features a low center of gravity, which provides enhanced stability and safety when lifting or operating on slopes.- Max travel speed: 7 mph
- Turning radius: 73 inches (tight)
Comparison of Bobcat S630 vs CAT 246D
Bobcat S630:
- Engine: 2.4L turbocharged diesel
- Horsepower: 74.3 hp
- Rated Operating Capacity: 2,300 lbs
- Operating Weight: 7,763 lbs
- Maximum Lift Height: 122 inches
- Hydraulic Flow (Standard): 24.5 GPM
- Hydraulic Flow (High Flow): Available up to 24.5 GPM
- Hydraulic Pressure: 3,500 psi
- Max Travel Speed: 7.5 mph
- Turning Radius: 74 inches
- Ride Control: Standard suspension undercarriage
CAT 246D:
- Engine: 2.2L turbocharged diesel
- Horsepower: 74.3 hp
- Rated Operating Capacity: 2,400 lbs
- Operating Weight: 7,775 lbs
- Maximum Lift Height: 121 inches
- Hydraulic Flow (Standard): 23.8 GPM
- Hydraulic Flow (High Flow): Available up to 33.2 GPM
- Hydraulic Pressure: 3,200 psi
- Max Travel Speed: 7 mph
- Turning Radius: 73 inches
- Ride Control: Optional ride control system
Key Differences Between the Bobcat S630 and CAT 246D
- Hydraulic Flow
The Bobcat S630 offers slightly higher hydraulic flow at 24.5 GPM compared to the CAT 246D’s 23.8 GPM. This slight difference can impact performance when using high-demand attachments, especially those requiring maximum hydraulic pressure. - Rated Operating Capacity
The CAT 246D has a higher rated operating capacity at 2,400 lbs compared to the Bobcat S630’s 2,300 lbs. This difference gives the 246D a slight edge when it comes to lifting heavier materials. - Lift Height
The Bobcat S630 offers a marginally higher lift height (122 inches) compared to the CAT 246D (121 inches). This could be a consideration for operators who need to load materials into higher trucks or containers. - Ride Control System
The CAT 246D offers an optional ride control system that can reduce machine bounce, making it a good choice for operators who work in rough conditions or need a smoother ride. The Bobcat S630 comes with a suspension undercarriage, providing a similar benefit but in a different form. - High Flow Options
While both models offer high-flow hydraulics, the CAT 246D can provide a higher flow rate (up to 33.2 GPM) compared to the Bobcat S630’s 24.5 GPM. This makes the 246D a better option for running larger, high-powered attachments.
Conclusion: Which Machine is Right for You?
Both the Bobcat S630 and CAT 246D are exceptional skid steer loaders with unique advantages. If you require a machine with a higher-rated operating capacity and a smoother ride in rough conditions, the CAT 246D might be the better choice. However, if you prioritize hydraulic performance and slightly higher lift heights, the Bobcat S630 may be the right fit.
Ultimately, the decision will depend on the specific needs of your worksite, the types of attachments you plan to use, and personal preferences regarding ride comfort and machine handling. Either way, both machines are built to deliver reliable performance in a variety of applications, making them solid investments for construction and material handling tasks.
